Chapter 8 - The Confrontation
The emergency hearing in the Surrogate’s Court of New York County, Part 4, took place at four o'clock on Friday afternoon in a courtroom that smelled of hundred-year-old varnish, wet wool coats, and the ozone from two commercial laser printers that had been running continuously since two-thirty.
Judge Harold Holtzman sat behind the high walnut bench with his spectacles pushed up onto his bald crown, his face the color of old parchment that had been left near a steam radiator.
On the right side of the aisle sat Arthur Montgomery, flanked by three senior partners from Cravath, Swaine & Moore. All three lawyers wore identical dark navy suits, white shirts with spread collars, and expressions of intense, professional melancholy, as if they were attending the reading of a will for an estate whose assets had unexpectedly been converted into Confederate script.
On the left side of the aisle sat Julian Cross.
Beside Julian sat Nora Vance.
She had refused to sit in the second row with the spectators. She sat at the long counsel table with her hands flat on the polished mahogany, wearing her brother’s green wool sweater and her work boots, her jaw set like a block of Hudson granite.
Ivy was not in the room. Marcus Hayes was sitting with her in the judge’s private library down the hall, where he had already disassembled three legal dictionaries to build a corral for the silver mechanical bird.
“Mr. Cross,” Judge Holtzman said, his voice raspy from forty years of tobacco and bench conferences. “This court has before it an ex-parte application from the Montgomery Foundation to seal the estate records of Elena Montgomery Cross pursuant to the three-year statutory presumption of death for issue not recovered.”
Julian did not stand up. He remained seated, his hands folded loosely over a single sheet of paper.
“The presumption is rebutted, Harold,” Julian said.
The lead partner for Cravath—a man named Sterling whose hair was so perfectly silvered it looked like nickel plating—rose to his feet with an offended rustle of silk-lined wool.
“Your Honor! Mr. Cross is not an attorney of record in this proceeding. If he wishes to introduce supplemental evidence at this late hour, it must be submitted through formal probate motion with forty-eight hours notice to the residual beneficiaries—”
“The residual beneficiaries are sitting in this room,” Julian said, cutting through Sterling’s silvered cadence without looking at him. “And one of them is currently facing six counts of insurance fraud, four counts of falsifying corporate records in the second degree, and one count of criminal solicitation in Ulster County.”
Arthur Montgomery did not move. He sat with both hands resting on the ivory fox head of his cane, his eyes fixed on the seal of the State of New York carved into the wood above the judge’s bench.
“Julian,” Judge Holtzman said, his voice dropping into a tone that was half-warning, half-plea. “This is a court of record. You cannot make allegations of that nature without—”
“The paper on your desk, Harold,” Julian said, pointing one finger toward the leather folder before the judge, “is not a medical affidavit. It is a forensic summary signed by Dr. Lindqvist and counter-signed by Dr. Chen at the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner of the City of New York. The child currently eating vanilla wafers in your private chambers is Lily Cross.”
Sterling turned his head toward Arthur Montgomery. Arthur did not return the look.
“Furthermore,” Julian said, his voice rising half an octave, filling the vaulted courtroom with that cold, terrifying resonance that had once cleared two trading floors in Frankfurt, “the Montgomery Foundation’s filing this morning was accompanied by an affidavit of diligence signed by Arthur Montgomery, asserting that no surviving issue had been identified despite exhaustive inquiry.”
Julian stood up slowly.
He was six inches taller than Sterling, his broad shoulders blocking the light from the tall casement windows behind the table.
“Nora Vance was interviewed by Arthur’s private investigators—Messrs. Keach and Dooley of White Plains—on October twelfth of twenty-one,” Julian said. “She was offered eighty thousand dollars in cash and a life tenancy in a property in Greene County if she would execute an unconditional surrender of an unnamed female infant to a private placement agency in Reno, Nevada.”
The courtroom went entirely silent.
The court reporter’s fingers hovered above the keys of her steno machine, her mouth slightly open.
“That’s an outrageous falsehood,” Sterling said, though his voice had lost its silver edge; it had developed a thin, tinny wobble at the end of the sentence.
Julian did not look at him. He reached into his coat pocket, pulled out a small, gray plastic thumb drive, and set it on the mahogany table with a sharp, dry *click.*
“The recording was made on Donald Vance’s micro-cassette dictaphone,” Julian said, looking directly at Arthur Montgomery’s profile. “Nora kept it in a tin box under the floorboards of the trailer. Keach and Dooley were very specific, Arthur. They told her that if the Cross baby showed up in New York, the Montgomery trust would remain in Julian Cross’s administrative control for eighteen years, and Arthur wouldn't be able to cover the seventy-million-dollar hole in the Bermuda reinsurance facility.”
Arthur Montgomery’s head twitched.
A tiny, wet sound came from his throat—a sound like a bubble bursting in thick oil.
Judge Holtzman reached for his glasses. He pulled them down onto the bridge of his nose, his eyes darting from the thumb drive on the table to Arthur’s white, rigid face, and finally to Nora Vance, who was still sitting with her red, chapped hands flat on the mahogany.
“Mr. Sterling,” Judge Holtzman whispered.
Sterling did not stand. He sat down slowly, his navy wool trousers bunching around his knees, his eyes fixed on his yellow legal pad where he had written the words: *PRESUMPTION - 36 MONTHS - FINAL.*
“Your Honor,” Sterling said, his voice scarcely audible above the hum of the printers. “My firm requests a twenty-four-hour adjournment to consult with our client regarding... the factual assertions in the Cross submission.”
“No,” Julian said.
The judge looked up. “Julian—”
“No adjournment,” Julian said. “The child has lived for thirty-two months without her name. She has lived in three trailers, two cold-water flats, and a basement on Forty-eighth Street while that old man used her mother’s money to buy polo ponies in Wellington.”
Julian reached out his left hand and took Nora’s rough, chapped fingers in his own.
He did not look at her, but his grip was firm, warm, and total.
“The court will enter an immediate order of parentage,” Julian said. “It will confirm Julian Cross as the biological father, and it will confirm Nora Vance as the child’s legal and permanent guardian with joint custody in perpetuity.”
Nora’s head jerked toward him. Her hazel eyes went wide, the breath catching in her throat with a sharp, dry gasp.
“Julian,” she whispered.
Julian did not let go of her hand. His fingers squeezed hers until her knuckles pressed together.
“And as for Arthur,” Julian continued, looking back at the bench, “the United States Attorney for the Southern District has already received the mirror files. The agents are waiting in the rotunda downstairs, Harold. If you grant an adjournment, they will execute the warrant in your hallway.”
Judge Harold Holtzman took off his glasses. He set them on the leather blotter, rubbed his eyes with both thumbs until his forehead was red, and then reached for the heavy wooden gavel that had belonged to his predecessor.
He looked at Arthur Montgomery.
“Arthur,” the judge said softly, his voice thick with thirty years of private dinners and shared clubs that had just come to a cold, dead end. “You should have stayed in the country.”
The gavel fell once: *crack.*
May you like
“Order of parentage granted,” Holtzman said. “Joint custody to Cross and Vance. The records of the Montgomery trust are impounded by the clerk of this court pending federal inquiry. Clear the room.”
***
