Chapter 8 - The Deposition

Two weeks later, the cold New England autumn had hardened into early winter. A dusting of crisp white snow outlined the black wrought-iron fences around Harvard Yard and capped the brick chimneys of Cambridge.
Inside the quiet, book-lined study of the Vance brownstone, Emily sat by the bay window with a cup of chamomile tea. Her LSAT study guides were once again open on the small oak writing desk, their margins filled with her neat, precise handwriting. The swelling on her left cheek had completely subsided, leaving behind only the faintest yellow shadow beneath the bone—a shadow that would fade entirely within days.
A soft knock sounded at the open door. Marcus Thorne, the United States Attorney for the District of Massachusetts, stepped inside. He had removed his heavy overcoat, revealing a sharp charcoal suit. In his hand, he carried a slim leather folder.
"Emily," Marcus said warmly, offering a respectful nod. "How are you feeling?"
"Better, Marcus. The morning sickness is finally easing up," Emily replied, setting her teacup down with a genuine smile. "Come in, please."
Arthur Vance entered behind him, carrying two bone-china mugs of black coffee. The Chief Judge had spent the morning in his personal library rather than at the courthouse, choosing to remain near his daughter during what he knew would be an emotionally demanding day.
"Marcus took Carter's formal deposition this morning in the presence of his retained defense counsel," Arthur said, handing a mug to the US Attorney before taking a seat in the leather wingback opposite Emily. "I thought you had a right to know the outcome before the formal press release."
Emily took a steady breath. She felt the tiny flutter in her lower abdomen—a faint, surreal reminder of the life taking root within her. "What happened?"
Marcus opened the folder on the corner of the desk. "Carter waived his right to silence under a proffer agreement, hoping to avoid federal conspiracy charges related to his father’s financial transactions. When we questioned him under oath about the incident in his mother’s apartment, he broke completely."
"Did he try to defend her?" Emily asked quietly.
"He did the exact opposite," Marcus said, his tone tinged with cold professional distaste. "He threw Barbara under the bus without hesitation. He testified that Barbara planned the abortion agreement entirely on her own, that she had drafted the non-disclosure clause through a private family attorney without his knowledge, and that he had explicitly begged her not to confront you. He provided phone records, text messages, and internal family emails showing that Barbara had threatened to disinherit him if he married you."
Emily stared down at the polished wood of the floor. There was no joy in hearing this—only a profound, hollow pity for a man who had possessed every advantage in life and yet owned not a single ounce of backbone.
"And Carter's position at the DOJ?" she asked.
"Terminated as of nine o'clock this morning," Marcus answered flatly. "The Department accepted his resignation in lieu of a formal misconduct trial. However, the Board of Bar Overseers has already opened disbarment proceedings based on his failure to report an attempted extortion and his participation in concealing assets. His career as an attorney is over, Emily. He will never practice law in this Commonwealth again."
"And William?"
Arthur spoke now, his deep voice carrying the calm weight of inexorable reality. "William has agreed to enter a guilty plea to two counts of securities fraud and one count of filing false tax returns. Sterling Vantage Capital will be liquidated by a court-appointed receiver to satisfy restitution orders. The penthouse on Commonwealth Avenue, the Cape Cod property, and their private investment vehicles will be forfeited to the government."
"And Barbara?" Emily asked, meeting her father's eyes.
"Barbara was formally indicted yesterday afternoon," Marcus answered. "Assault and battery, witness intimidation, and attempted extortion. Because of the nature of the physical assault against a pregnant woman, the Suffolk County District Attorney is proceeding with maximum charges. Her defense counsel attempted to negotiate a diversion program. We declined. She will stand trial, or she will plead guilty to a felony on the public record."
Emily closed her eyes for a moment. The memory of Barbara's contemptuous glare across the table at Locke-Ober, the cold slap that had echoed off the marble floor of the Back Bay penthouse, the cruel laughter of Ashley—it had all happened less than a month ago. In four short weeks, the towering monument of Sterling arrogance had been reduced to rubble, not through violence or vengeance, but through the calm, methodical application of the law they had treated as an inconvenience.
"Emily," Marcus said gently, closing the folder. "Carter asked if he could see you. Just once. He asked if he could deliver a letter of apology in person."
Emily opened her eyes. They were clear, dark, and entirely untroubled by regret.
"No," she said. "Tell him that the only communication he will ever have regarding this family will come through my attorney when custody and support arrangements are formally filed. He wanted nothing to do with this child when he thought it would cost him his mother’s favor. He will not use my baby to buy back his reputation."
Arthur looked at his daughter, and in his slate-gray eyes, there was an unmistakable glow of fierce, unshakeable pride.
May you like
"A very proper ruling, counselor," Arthur said softly.
***