Chapter 3 - The Tea in the Pantry

I slept for four uninterrupted hours.
When I woke at 4:30 a.m., the sky outside was still dark gray, but the crushing fog in my brain had cleared. Lily was gone—Sophia had clearly retrieved her during the night—leaving only her one-eared gray rabbit sitting neatly on my nightstand.
I picked up the rabbit, feeling the worn fur under my fingers.
I dressed in my usual suit, skipped the morning espresso, and walked down the grand marble staircase to the ground floor. The house was quiet.
In the kitchen, Sophia was standing at the stainless steel island, slicing apples for Lily’s breakfast. When she heard my footsteps, she spun around, her face turning pale.
“Mr. Moretti!” she gasped, dropping the paring knife onto the board. “I am so, so sorry about last night. I don't know how she slipped out of the cottage. The latch was loose, and she must have—”
“Sophia,” I cut her off gently.
She froze, holding her hands together, trembling slightly. She was twenty-eight, quiet, hardworking, and had been recommended to me by Mrs. Ricci two years ago after her husband passed away in a highway accident. She had always kept her distance, ensuring Lily stayed out of my way.
“She left her rabbit,” I said, setting the gray plush toy on the counter.
Sophia blinked, looking at the rabbit, then up at my face. She noticed something immediately—the absence of the heavy, dark purple circles under my eyes.
“Did... did she disturb you terribly?” Sophia whispered.
“I slept four hours,” I said quietly.
Sophia breathed out a slow, trembling breath. “Mrs. Ricci told her yesterday afternoon that you were sick because you never sleep. Lily takes things very literally. She told me last night she was going to perform ‘surgery’ on your eyes with her storybook.”
I sat on a high stool at the kitchen island. “What was the tea she mentioned?”
Sophia paused, her fingers fidgeting with the hem of her apron. “Tea?”
“Last night, Lily said people tried doctors, medicine, and tea. She said the tea didn't work.”
Sophia’s expression shifted subtly—a tiny flicker of hesitation passed across her features before she smoothed it over. “Oh. Mrs. Ricci makes chamomile for you sometimes, doesn't she? Lily must have seen her carrying the tray up last month.”
“I don't drink chamomile,” I said. “My cousin Marco brings me a specific herbal blend from his estate in Calabria. He swore it was meant to calm the nerves.”
“Right,” Sophia said quickly, turning back to the apples. “Marco’s tea. Of course.”
I watched her back. My instincts—honed by decades in an industry where hesitation meant death—pricked up. Sophia was a terrible liar. Her shoulders were tense, her breathing shallow.
“Sophia.”
May you like
She stopped cutting.
“What do you know about that tea?”