Chapter 5 - The Discovery Deposition
The air in the conference room of Francine’s law firm was thick with tension on a humid Tuesday morning in early June. Across the polished oak table sat Dustin, flanked by his attorney, Henderson, and accompanied—much to our shock—by Judith herself, who had insisted on attending her son’s deposition despite the pending restraining order.
"She cannot be in this room," Francine stated instantly, slamming her pen down on the table. "The protective order explicitly bars Judith Vance from being within five hundred feet of my client or her minor child. While Meadow isn't here, Mrs. Vance’s presence is an overt act of intimidation."
"My client has a right to support her son during legal proceedings," Henderson argued smoothly.
"Not when her presence constitutes ongoing harassment," Francine shot back, her voice ringing with authority. "Unless Mrs. Vance leaves this floor immediately, I am calling the bailiff and filing an emergency motion for contempt of court."
Judith’s eyes narrowed into venomous slits. She looked like she wanted to spit poison across the table, but the sharp glare Henderson shot her warned her of the legal peril. With a huff of deep indignation, Judith gathered her designer handbag, stood up so sharply her chair scraped loudly against the linoleum, and swept out of the room, slamming the heavy glass door behind her.
Dustin flinched as the door clicked shut, looking utterly abandoned.
"Now, Mr. Vance," Francine said, leaning forward and fixing him with a gaze of absolute ice. "Let’s talk about your childhood, your financial dependence on your mother, and your explicit authorization of physical violence against your eight-year-old daughter."
Dustin swallowed hard, nervously adjusting his collar. "It wasn't violence. I already told your sister—"
"Mr. Vance," Francine interrupted, sliding a printed text message log across the table. "Do you recognize this transcript? This is the text exchange between you and your mother on May 12th at 4:15 PM. Your mother texted: 'She is getting vain. I’m taking the clippers to her hair to teach her some humility.' Your response, sent exactly two minutes later, was: 'Do whatever you think is best. She needs to learn.'"
"Yes," Dustin muttered, staring fixedly at his hands. "I was busy. I trusted her."
"Did you know that when your mother applied the clippers, she cut the skin near Meadow’s ear so deeply that it bled?" Francine asked, her voice dropping to a dangerous whisper.
Dustin’s head snapped up. "She... she didn't mention any blood."
May you like
"Of course she didn't," I spoke up for the first time, my voice trembling with controlled fury. "Because you didn't ask, Dustin. You never asked how your daughter was doing. You only asked how it was going to affect your schedule, your peace of mind, and your mother’s fragile ego."
Dustin opened his mouth to reply, but no words came out. The absolute truth of my accusation hung heavy in the air, suffocating every rehearsed excuse he and his attorney had prepared.
